|
|
Post by gunsmithcat on Aug 7, 2014 14:10:46 GMT -4
Recently someone asked at a different board about who are the best vocalists in Korea and Japan with some default choices, and when i meantioned that Nana should be a part of this poll, and provided some live videos as examples, i was told i would a delusional f-tard and that Nana is at best at the singing level of AKB48 and similar groups. At best. While this at least proves that internet access doesn't require an intelligence check, i wonder how anyone over here would rate her singing abilities from 1 - 10.
|
|
|
|
Post by Vívace on Aug 7, 2014 16:01:31 GMT -4
It's no surprise the internet holds lots of hate without reason.
If you even try to say on anime forums that "insert popular/top ranked show" isn't your cup of tea and you don't like it, the first response is telling you to go kill yourself or why did you even post. Same if you go on a popular YouTube channel.
Well anyway, I know Nana isn't perfect and neither is her accuracy and voice. Nobody will be prefect no matter how professional you become or however many years you sing. But darn, compare her to 98% of other J-pop singers and there's a difference. Nana isn't a god or a goddess at singing but she's fantastic at what she tries to do. Her dedication to singing shows in how she wants to try new things. Her vocals are superb as she can sing many genres. It doesn't take much cleaning at all for her CD and lives. What else do I want? What else am I suppose to expect?
Obviously 10/10. tl;dr Nana will never be perfect but she's already darn better than almost all other singers and dedicated to her job.
|
|
|
|
Post by stranger on Aug 8, 2014 1:17:10 GMT -4
Nana's singing ability is what drew me into her in the first place. It's something really special, and not many female vocalists from Japan have that powerful voice she does.
The only downside to her may be her range. However, she makes up with that in character, like songs like Lovely Fruit/Discotheque she sings in a completely different voice than Bring It On!/Mysterion. She has great control of her voice.
I don't want to give her a 9, but it's hard to give someone a 10 because that makes them seem like they're perfect. Even so, I'm giving her a 10 because her vocals are among my favorite in the J-pop industry.
|
|
|
|
Post by hot0rikun967 on Aug 9, 2014 15:09:02 GMT -4
We've probably all seen this: but just for comparison, here's Nana with some AKB48 members, slaying. www.youtube.com/watch?v=o7tT_IpYjFgBest vocalist in anison genre, best Jpop/Jrock singer I've ever heard right up with GACKT. |
|
